Edmonton Property Management. Who Sucks and Who Rocks?, Take this Poll to share your input Options

[GSI]

On our REIN MYSPACE forum we talk a lot about which residential property managers are good and bad, as well as ways to improve self-managing.

I thought that it would be helpful to make a list of Edmonton property managers (you could do a similar post for your city too) and rate them. The key is to add both your positive and negative feedback. Some property managers should just plain be avoided- don't be shy to write that. Others deserve more recognition for doing a great job- add that too.

I wanted to add a space for comments under the direct polls, but wasn't able too. therefore, please just add your comments under the company names below. If I missed some major property managers, please add them.

1) Realty Corp. (Liberty Manor)

2) Kirkside Realty

3) Realty Canada (Don King)

4) Libertas Property Management Inc.

5) Davis Management and Realty (was Brent Davis)

6) Terra Realty (DMG/Don Grey)

7) Assured Property Management (Macdonald Realty - John Stobbe)

8) Group Three Property Management

9) Larlyn Property Management (condo)

10) Mayfield (condo)

11) Esquire Management Group

12) Milligan Realty Ltd.

13) Blue Print Property Management

14) Ayre & Oxford Inc.

15) Bella property Management


Someone I forgot? Please add them below:

This post has been edited by GSI: Feb 3 2009, 02:03 PM

[MichaelBradfield]

On our REIN MYSPACE forum we talk a lot about which residential property managers are good and bad, as well as ways to improve self-managing.

I thought that it would be helpful to make a list of Edmonton property managers (you could do a similar post for your city too) and rate them. The key is to add both your positive and negative feedback. Some property managers should just plain be avoided- don't be shy to write that. Others deserve more recognition for doing a great job- add that too.

I wanted to add a space for comments under the direct polls, but wasn't able too. therefore, please just add your comments under the company names below. If I missed some major property managers, please add them.

1) Realty Corp. (Liberty Manor)

2) Kirkside Realty

3) Realty Canada (Don King)- XXXXX - never ever use this joker. Cost us thousands to repair the damage his welfare tenants caused.
He never answers the phone, never calls back, and left us with numerous months with no tenants. Bad all around.

4) Libertas Holdings Inc.

5) Davis Management and Realty (was Brent Davis)

6) Terra Realty (DMG/Don Grey)

7) Assured Property Management (Macdonald Realty - John Stobbe)

8) Group Three Property Management

9) Larlyn Property Management (condo)

10) Mayfield (condo)

11) Esquire Management Group

12) Milligan Realty Ltd.

13) Blue Print Property Management

14) Ayre & Oxford Inc.

15) Bella property Management


Someone I forgot? Please add them below:

[JNB]

... 13) Blue Print Property Management - I had a very good experienc with Blue Print I was dealing with Kim for a year and a half. Too bad she is no longer providing the PM service. She is now doing the bailiff side of the bussiness.

This post id such a good idea...thanks!

This post has been edited by JNB: Feb 2 2009, 06:13 AM

[vandriani]

1) Realty Corp. (Liberty Manor)

2) Kirkside Realty

3) Realty Canada (Don King)

4) Libertas Holdings Inc. - I like the idea iof using a landlord liason, lease-up took longer than I expected, monthly account statements are not very explainatory an very organized. I know of one owner that has fired this company (not me).

5) Davis Management and Realty (was Brent Davis)

6) Terra Realty (DMG/Don Grey)

7) Assured Property Management (Macdonald Realty - John Stobbe)

8) Group Three Property Management

9) Larlyn Property Management (condo)

10) Mayfield (condo)

11) Esquire Management Group

12) Milligan Realty Ltd.

13) Blue Print Property Management

14) Ayre & Oxford Inc.

15) Bella property Management

[klewlis]

3) Realty Canada (Don King)- XXXXX - never ever use this joker. Cost us thousands to repair the damage his welfare tenants caused.
He never answers the phone, never calls back, and left us with numerous months with no tenants. Bad all around.

I have heard similar feedback about him never returning calls and not seeming to care if units sit empty.

However, I do take issue with the phrase "the damage his welfare tenants caused." That smacks of discrimination... which appears to be a HUGE problem among Edmonton landlords... (perhaps elsewhere too, I don't know).

[Ian]

On our REIN MYSPACE forum we talk a lot about which residential property managers are good and bad, as well as ways to improve self-managing.

I thought that it would be helpful to make a list of Edmonton property managers (you could do a similar post for your city too) and rate them. The key is to add both your positive and negative feedback. Some property managers should just plain be avoided- don't be shy to write that. Others deserve more recognition for doing a great job- add that too.

I wanted to add a space for comments under the direct polls, but wasn't able too. therefore, please just add your comments under the company names below. If I missed some major property managers, please add them.

1) Realty Corp. (Liberty Manor)

2) Kirkside Realty

3) Realty Canada (Don King)

4) Libertas Holdings Inc.

5) Davis Management and Realty (was Brent Davis)

6) Terra Realty (DMG/Don Grey)

7) Assured Property Management (Macdonald Realty - John Stobbe)

8) Group Three Property Management

9) Larlyn Property Management (condo)

10) Mayfield (condo)

11) Esquire Management Group

12) Milligan Realty Ltd.

13) Blue Print Property Management

14) Ayre & Oxford Inc.

15) Bella property Management


Someone I forgot? Please add them below:

Kirkside--suck absolutely 100%--they completely lack integtrity and honesty--if you want to have your units vacant for four or five months and then have Caroline ok tenants who destroy your units and then bolt in the middle of the night then KIRKISIDE is the PM company for you.

This post has been edited by Ian: Feb 2 2009, 12:52 PM

[GSI]

Kirkside--suck absolutely 100%--they completely lack integtrity and honesty--if you want to have your units vacant for four or five months and then have Caroline ok tenants who destroy your units and then bolt in the middle of the night then KIRKISIDE is the PM company for you.

Great info from everyone who has posted. Let's keep this going so we can really dig deep and evaluate who we trust to look after our assets. Keep your comments coming, the good the bad and the ugly (Kirkside).

[ChrisDavies]

I had fun working at Davies Management, and I think they do a pretty good job, but maybe I'm biased.

I did vote for a couple other firms there who I think do a good job.

And it's Davies with an 'e'.

[JessiePaul]

Please DO NOT use Kirkside. I agree with Ian, they are completely incompetent! You can never get an answer when you want one, the statements don't make any sense. She never returns phone calls. I am still waiting for payment after 2 months! Absolutely terrible service!

This post has been edited by JessiePaul: Feb 2 2009, 08:23 PM

[GSI]

I had fun working at Davies Management, and I think they do a pretty good job, but maybe I'm biased.

I did vote for a couple other firms there who I think do a good job.

And it's Davies with an 'e'.

Hi Chris, Thanks for your comments. Sorry about the spelling error.

I guess that you would be a bit biased seeing as your Dad did own the company
He's always been great on the phone when I spoke to him although I never have directly worked with him.

For voting purposes, please select folks that you have actually worked with as opposed to those that you 'think' are good. We all try and choose a PM that we 'think' is good and are frustrated when they turn out to be less than that. By voting we can rate their actual performance.

Thank you,

[JNB]

It is good to see the number of votes, but It would also be nice to have some feedback "why" one voted for a given PM or PMs.

Thanks!

[gwasser]

On our REIN MYSPACE forum we talk a lot about which residential property managers are good and bad, as well as ways to improve self-managing.

14) Ayre & Oxford Inc.

I use Ayre & Oxford and I think they are good. They manage a small rental pool of a 15 unit appartment building in which I participate. Their statmements are somewhat confusing and it is not always easy to figure out what is going on long-distance (I live in Calgary). But when I call I always get decent clarification. They also managed a significant renovation of one of my units in a very efficient and prudent fashion. They even let me repay the reno costs out of cashflow over several months. (the reno involved new carpet, repainting, new appliances and bath tub restoration). Once they hired a poor on-site manager with vacancies sky-rocketing - but they fired the manager within 3 months. Also, they have sometimes trouble dealing with poor renters that reduce the bottom line. Overall I am quite happy and have received good service over the last 3 years.

[EdWhittingham]

I highly recommend Libertas Property Management. Very professional, responsive, and well praised by tenants, owners and condo associations (as I've discovered through my own experiences and through due diligence checks). Tyler and his crew work very hard on our behalf, and I'm pleased to have them represent me. A new web-based system will enable owners to access property-specific info on demand - I'm looking forward to it.

Avoid Don King and Realty Canada! As per a previous post, he is difficult to reach by both tenants and owners, and attracts very challenging tenants. He too cost me a lot of money by being MIA.

Ed Whittingham

[GSI]

I highly recommend Libertas Property Management. Very professional, responsive, and well praised by tenants, owners and condo associations (as I've discovered through my own experiences and through due diligence checks). Tyler and his crew work very hard on our behalf, and I'm pleased to have them represent me. A new web-based system will enable owners to access property-specific info on demand - I'm looking forward to it.

Avoid Don King and Realty Canada! As per a previous post, he is difficult to reach by both tenants and owners, and attracts very challenging tenants. He too cost me a lot of money by being MIA.

Ed Whittingham

Great feedback, Ed, JNB and Godfried (by the way I really enjoy your posts and your perspective on things

There has got to be more folks out there that can add comments to their experience using PMs in Edmonton - come on and share with us!

Thank you,

This post has been edited by GSI: Feb 6 2009, 12:39 AM

[mponte]

I use Davies Management and can't say enough good things about them. Very professional, organized and they are great with our tenants.

Great feedback, Ed, JNB and Godfried (by the way I really enjoy your posts and your perspective on things

There has got to be more folks out there that can add comments to their experience using PMs in Edmonton - come on and share with us!

Thank you,